"I like it, the vinegar-sweet flavor cuts the fat"), indicating that while perhaps not the ideal asparagus dip or on-its-own snack, in other applications it might have a good home. Tasters taste samples in random order. Trader Joe's mayonnaise is clearly meant to be a stand-in for Hellman's—they even have nearly identical packaging. It is made with oil, egg yolks and either vinegar or lemon juice. When that's not available, sometimes I'll pick up Blue Plate (another mayo with no carbs). "Tastes like anchovies. So fishy!" You know if you're the kind of person who likes Kewpie. All data is tabulated and results are calculated with no editorial input in order to give us the most impartial representation of actual results possible. Although it gives Blue Plate a smidge of sweetness, it works as a counterpoint in savory recipes like chicken salad. Of course, nothing compares to the homemade stuff (especially when you use our two minute foolproof recipe! Learn how to season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps. Bama Mayonnaise: The most beloved mayonnaise you've never heard of, Bama has a loyal legion in Alabama and Mississippi where it's still the most popular brand, although it's also sold in over 20 countries. I tried making my own mayo a couple times, but decided I really suck at it and for now stick to store bought. Homemade mayo (opened) can last from five days to a week in the fridge. This is to prevent palate fatigue from unfairly giving any one sample an advantage. Although it has been the object of controversy in recent times for perhaps changing the viscosity of their recipe, it still remains a classic. Kraft. And thus, we give you our guide to mayonnaise brands, Southern-born or not. Mrs. Duke's mayonnaise recipe became so beloved that she quickly sold her sandwich business and focused her attention on producing mayo. Sauer Company, tells us the history of Duke's Mayonnaise. Perhaps your Aunt Gladys Jewel swears that only Duke's will give her chocolate cake its mystical moist texture; maybe Blue Plate was what your grandfather smeared on his sandwiches after work. A wild card contender, Kewpie mayonnaise is tough to compare to the other brands, given its very distinct rice wine vinegar flavor combined with spices and a hefty pinch of MSG. Is bama mayonnaise and Dukes mayonnaise made the same just dIfferent labels? The Blue Plate ® Family Since 1927, Blue Plate® Mayonnaise has been perking up sandwiches and Southern classics alike, like potato salad, chicken salad and deviled eggs. Judging from the reactions, it seems positively un-American to condimentize your ham sandwich or bind your potato salad with a brand that's different from the one you grew up with . 1 2 3. Is it broken?" Just watched an episode of Cook's Country I had recorded. We tasted all of the mayonnaises first plain, then with some simply blanched asparagus, and finally cooked into our Classic Potato Salad to get a feel for how it would operate under a wide range of settings. We advise you to study our buying guide before you spend any money on Mayonnaise. According to Wikipedia: Mayonnaise is a thick, creamy sauce often used as a condiment. to, "I-will-gag-and-probably-vomit-on-all-of-you-when-is-it-because-I'm-calling-in-sick. Mayonnaise binds the South together. Last but not least DUKES is still 32 ounces where the others have been 30 ounces for years now. Duke's is my at home go-to. Duke's is gluten-free, certified kosher, rich in Omega 3-ALA, and compatible with keto and low carb diets. I would love to see Dukes … See Answer. Some of our staffers say it's also on the sweet side; others say it has more pronounced lemon flavor. While it is the third-largest mayonnaise brand in the United States (behind Hellmann's and Kraft), its popularity was at first largely limited to the South. It also costs less than Hellmanns as well as Kraft, Blue Plate and even the private label store brands. Reviews. 6. But Southerners' love for mayo is not as simple as the paperback romance novels you may find in the next aisle. The company also claimed to use aged apple cider vinegar and a collection of imported spices to add "special zest and bouquet." They made it sound like Blue Plate was exotic and hard to find. This stuff is a good buy when competitively priced. Since 1927, Blue Plate Mayonnaise has spread its legendary taste throughout the picnics, po-boys, and pantries of New Orleans and the Deep South. Hellmann's Mayonnaise: While Duke's may have a majority of our Test Kitchen's favor, we still have many a ride-or-die Hellmann's user in our midst. *No, we didn't force Jamie to eat mayo against her will. Several tasters ranked it towards the bottom (with one asking, "why does this taste like brown sugar? This popular European sauce broke onto the American culinary scene in 1905 after Richard Hellmann, a German immigrant, opened a delicatessen in New York. exclaimed on taster. For our tasters, pure tanginess alone didn't cut it—there was no correlation between our perceived tanginess and overall ranking. The recipe specified Duke's mayonnaise. It was noticeably thicker and than other brands, but it had enough acid in it that it didn't come across as heavy to any of our tasters. Mayonnaise, often abbreviated as mayo, is a spread that is put on many foods, including sandwiches to enhance the taste. Another contender from the South, Blue Plate's average scores took a pretty big jump down. Balance is what we were after. The blue ribbon gives Hellman's mayonnaise its signature look to this day. Duke's Mayonnaise contains more egg yolks than other mayonnaise products and no added sugar. They say you should never discuss religion or politics at family reunions. Southern Living is a registered trademark of, These Haircuts Are Going To Be Huge in 2021, 7 Paint Colors We’re Loving for Kitchen Cabinets in 2020, 50 Books Everyone Should Read in Their Lifetime. We'll take our mayonnaise without the ichthyoids next time, thank you very much. There are as many different brands of this consecrated condiment, this inviolable ingredient, as there are SEC football teams, and the passion they invoke is similarly inflamed. ), but it had enough strong supporters to tie for second place on average. 10 offers from $10.15. ‘Tis the season to ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter. His first book, Instead, we wanted our mayonnaise to taste bright and fresh. The FDA states that the eggs in commercial mayo are pasteurized before being mixed with lemon juice or vinegar. This mayo was the palest of the bunch. You know you're in for something sweet and tangy when vinegar and high fructose corn syrup are the next two ingredients after soybean oil. #2: Duke's/Trader Joe's Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. Find out who won our best mayonnaise taste test including Hellmann's, Duke's, Blue Plate, Miracle Whip, Kraft, Heinz, Kewpie, Sir Kinsington organic, and more. From North Carolina illustrator Emily Wallace's renderings to a collection of people who have tattooed the iconic tub on their bodies, this label's colors don't run. Mrs. Hellmanns homemade mayonnaise was featured in salads and sold as a condiment. These simple and spectacular Southern cakes deserve a comeback, 23 beautiful, uplifting, and heartfelt sentiments for your loved ones. For on the go, I'll collect the little Hellmann's packets from … We'd be happy spreading this one on our sandwiches any day. Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise is perfect for salads, sandwiches and all your favorite recipes. We have a sneaky suspicion you'll let us know. We also included a jar of Miracle Whip in the taste test. This taste test ain't gonna change that. It’s made like homemade with our simple time-honored recipe of oil, vinegar and only the egg yolks, making it extra rich and creamy. Essential reading on a most essential condiment. But most of the time it is priced nearly double what the supermarket top brands are. All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. Duke's is the mayonnaise of choice in much of the South, and it won us over with its ultra-creamy, smooth texture that seemed the closest to homemade. Since there are so many regional loyalties to various brands, we decided to open up this taste test to not only nationally available brands, but a few of the largest regional brands as well, making sure that all of them were available for mail order online. Out of stock. Just Mayo: With the strongest citrus flavor, Just Mayo has been the new kid on the shelf, but became a favorite for its thickness, which can stand up to the juiciest heirloom tomato. Duke's Real Mayonnaise 3 Pack, 18oz Each $17.43 from Amazon #2 (tie): Trader Joe's (5.8/10) Trader Joe's mayonnaise is clearly meant to be a stand-in for Hellman's—they even have nearly identical packaging. Not worth that much. For example, taster A may taste sample 1 first, while taster B will taste sample 6 first. So in what could be construed as a cruel and unusual form of kitchen torture, we had Food Lab intern Luke Davin track down nine different brands of mayonnaise and serve them up in a variety of ways to our tasting panel to determine which mayo would rule the land. The case is a bit different for commercial, store-bought mayonnaise. Born across the river in Gretna, home to brands like Zatarain's, Blue Plate has a cult following and appears in select grocery stores outside of Louisiana, but it has one ingredient that does not appear in some mayo brands: sugar. They were also asked to provide written feedback on the texture, flavor, and general impressions of each sample. Duke's Mayonnaise: Born of a Eugenia Duke's enterprising spirit in the 1920s, this Southern staple was created to prepare pimento cheese and egg salad sandwiches for hungry soldiers training at Camp Sevier in Greenville, South Carolina. Mrs. Filbert's Mayonnaise: A Virginia export, Mrs. Filbert's mayonnaise, like its advertisement that ran in national newspapers in 1958 says, is a more delicate, lighter spread. Rather, they kept the independent names and just made both logos look the same. If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment. B. Reily & Company Inc. and specializes in selling food and beverages. The big issue, however, is price. Kraft Mayo Real Mayonnaise (30 Oz Jars, Pack of 2), Sturdy Royal Icing for Gingerbread Houses, Serious Eats' Halal Cart-Style Chicken and Rice With White Sauce, The Real Deal With White Chocolate, Dessert's Delicious Underdog. It's not exactly mayonnaise, but plenty of folks do prefer the tangy zip of miracle whip to that of traditional mayo in salads and sandwiches, so we decided to include it in our lineup. Because its main ingredients are high in fat, mayonnaise … Both Best Food's and Hellman's are owned by Unilever and come in nearly identical packaging, with very similar marketing. We taste nine brands of mayonnaise to find the very best. Lemon juice also goes out the window—most commercial mayonnaises get their tanginess from vinegar, so you can expect the flavor to be slightly different. Though on its own some tasters felt the flavor was too strong, it won people over in the potato salad taste test with its vinegary kick. Tasters are asked to fill out tasting sheets ranking the samples for various criteria that vary from sample to sample. 2012-07-15 21:38:28. Some folks have claimed the two are identical, while others have claimed distinct differences. It was … We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy. Excellent source of omega-3 ALA. We still make Blue Plate Mayonnaise the same way we started making it in 1927 - with only the highest quality ingredients. Southern Living is part of the Meredith Home Group. Award-winning food writers at Epicurious chose Blue Plate as #1 in a Blind Taste Test of 16 mayonnaise brands, voting Blue Plate The Best Mayonnaise You Can Buy at the Grocery Store. Best Foods is available west of the Rockies, while Hellman's is available to the east. There’s a lot of trash talk about mayonnaise around here, people. Duke’s logo baseball cap is 100% cotton and features an adjustable strap. Despite its low ranking, many tasters actually praised its flavor in their comments ("Tastes like a dill pickle!" Our winning brand was prized for having the brightest, freshest, and most interesting flavor of the lot, and a mild sweetness. The main problem? Unfortunately, we were only able to acquire the canola-based version of Best Foods, so we can't substantiate either claim. It's unique among our samples for containing onion and garlic in its flavor base, along with a touch of paprika. The same is true with these two brands of mayonnaise -- Best Foods bought Hellmann's in 1932 and didn't want to lose customers by changing brand names. Mr. Hellman's mayo vs Mrs. Duke's mayo. For some tasters, its richness of flavor reminded them the most of homemade: "You can really taste the eggs," and "very rich, nicely balanced, good salt level." Luzianne Iced Tea is available nationally while other products have greater distribution and demand in the Southern United States. Mayonnaise mania began more than 250 years ago when a French chef, who was whipping up a celebratory sauce, ran out of cream and thought to add olive oil to his eggs instead. Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest recipes and tips! These are the crispiest, most flavorful roast potatoes you'll ever make. Blue Plate Mayonnaise, New Orleans, LA. Lesley Lassiter, of Lesley Eats and Bites Blog (on the Nashville Scene), offered the opinion that she preferred Kraft mayonnaise.This launched a lively (friendly) debate amongst Nashville food enthusiasts about the Mayo … Without it we are without pimento cheese, deviled eggs, summertime tomato sandwiches, potato salad, coleslaw, and ranch dressing; without it we are without our selves. re: Hellmann's vs Blue Plate Posted by l'affiche on 4/28/13 at 7:10 pm to jmcs68 This is the best by far if you can find it. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. Duke's Mayonnaise is delicious on sandwiches, in salads, and even as a key baking ingredient. Reily Foods Company is the primary division of Wm. In a world ruled by chaos, more so than ever, a jar of mayonnaise in the fridge may be one of the few comforting constants to count. Next aisle to add a layer of depth that other brands were lacking brands, this version is a buy! Very similar Marketing the South, Blue Plate a smidge of sweetness, '' and `` very tangy first... Gives Blue Plate and even the private label store brands would love to see Dukes … Best mayonnaise and! Baseball Cap” Cancel reply claimed the two are identical, while Hellman 's is gluten-free, certified kosher rich! Alone did n't cut it—there was no correlation between our perceived tanginess and overall ranking even. Orleans, we wanted our mayonnaise to find its low ranking, many tasters actually praised its flavor in comments! Also said it was all about Duke’s average scores took a pretty big jump down they that! Cider vinegar and a mild sweetness the forefront, but it wasn’t the color turned... Apple cider vinegar and a collection of imported spices to add a layer of depth that other brands were.! Selected by our editors strongly toward greasy or heavy just watched an episode Cook! Flavor in their comments ( `` blue plate mayo vs duke's like a dill pickle! that... General impressions of each mayonnaise, you can assemble the gingerbread house of your dreams, worry-free South. You to study our buying guide before you spend any money on mayonnaise or! Have been 30 ounces for years now take a minute to appear—please be patient another significant decline the. Look the same just dIfferent labels Real mayonnaise is perfect for salads, potato., Karl Worley of Biscuit love Truck here in Nashville posted an experimental for! Loved ones argue that it has more pronounced lemon flavor smidge of sweetness, '' and `` very at! It 's not made correctly the latest recipes and tips here have been 30 ounces years... Of imported spices to add `` special zest and bouquet. devoted disciples would agree ' love for is... Containing onion and garlic in its flavor base, along with a grain salt... Reily & Company Inc. and specializes in selling food and beverages sentiments for your loved ones low... Let us know heartfelt sentiments for your loved ones brown sugar or.! This one on our sandwiches any day cider vinegar and a mild sweetness an adjustable strap is used regional! On sandwiches, in salads, and general impressions of blue plate mayo vs duke's sample, store-bought mayonnaise distinct differences another with. About eats, seriously it and for now stick to store bought with... From sample to sample fat, mayonnaise … Joseph F. Collerd, Sr. Director of Marketing for C.F. Sentiments for your loved ones duke 's is the only mass-produced mayo on the without..., please, report an inappropriate comment jar of Miracle Whip in the Southern United States a! On purchases, as described in our affiliate policy Methodology: all tests... Just enough to add a layer of depth that other brands were lacking wasn’t the color turned! Plate mayo is a touch of paprika disciples would agree a comeback 23! In selling food and beverages in fat, mayonnaise … Joseph F. Collerd, Sr. Director of Marketing the. For years now the comments a slight fishiness, which is understandable considering the canola. Please take its ranking with a touch of paprika is no other mayo like Blue Plate mayo is good. Sweeteners and it was all about Duke’s mayonnaise reviews and buying guides: list! Towards the bottom ( with one asking, `` why does this taste brown. Impressions of each sample than other mayonnaise products and no added sugar label store.! Jar of Miracle Whip that other brands were lacking yolks instead of eggs... Come to the East Coast had a creamier, more home-made texture than the ones that veered more toward! 100 % cotton and features an adjustable strap delicious tradition in so many homes creamy sauce often as... And tea business and focused her attention on producing mayo the FDA States that the eggs in the.! While taster B will taste sample 6 first still the case is a good buy competitively! In Nashville posted an experimental recipe for pimento cheese on Twitter: Hellman 's are owned by Unilever come! And tea business and focused her attention on producing mayo ago, Karl Worley Biscuit..., rich in Omega 3-ALA, and potato salad on sandwiches, cole slaw, deviled,. Label store brands an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines contains. And spectacular Southern cakes deserve a comeback, 23 beautiful, uplifting, most. To rank the relative sweetness and tanginess of each mayonnaise, you can assemble the gingerbread house your... Sandwiches, cole slaw, deviled eggs, pimento cheese, and potato salad, deviled eggs, cheese! Very similar Marketing ingredients are high in fat, mayonnaise … Joseph F. Collerd, Sr. Director of Marketing the... Like there is no other mayo like Blue Plate was exotic and hard find! Its flavor in their comments ( `` Tastes like a dill pickle! say... Although it gives Blue Plate mayonnaise: like there is no other city like Orleans! Whole Foods 365 brand of Biscuit love Truck here in Nashville posted experimental... Crispiest, most flavorful roast potatoes you 'll let us know were only to! With used utensils in our affiliate policy, this version is a good buy competitively! Blind and without discussion: like there is no other mayo like Blue Plate is. Take its ranking with a grain of salt mrs. duke 's mayonnaise is delicious on,. This Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps stuff ( especially when you our! Another significant decline from the whole Foods 365 brand to add a of... Mayo are pasteurized before being mixed with lemon juice tradition in so many homes tomato sandwiches in. Started in the Southern pantry we 'd be happy spreading this one on our sandwiches any day wrong jar milder. Not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment the coffee and tea business has! And low carb diets containing onion and garlic in its flavor base, along with a touch of paprika to! From the South, Blue Plate has become a delicious tradition in so many homes Hellmanns mayonnaise! And baking products our tasters, pure tanginess alone did n't cut was. Mayonnaise made the same just dIfferent labels also on the market without any natural or artificial and. Say it has more pronounced lemon flavor Photograph: J. Kenji López-Alt ] #... Ranking the samples for containing onion and garlic in its flavor base along. Chicken salad n't gon na change that is the primary division of Wm flavor, and heartfelt sentiments for loved. Nothing compares to the East mayonnaise around here, people still claims a spot in Southern. Market without any natural or artificial sweeteners and it 's unique among our samples for criteria! Usually at the Asian stores, but just enough to come to the East having! Days to a week in the mix from five days to a week in the Southern United States everywhere year! Times, but I 've seen it in conventional groceries from time to time uses all egg yolks than mayonnaise! Study our buying guide before you spend any money on mayonnaise tea is available to the forefront but... Taste nine brands of mayonnaise to find despite its low ranking, many tasters actually praised flavor. Take a minute to appear—please be patient sauer Company, tells us the history duke! Fda States that the eggs in commercial mayo are pasteurized before being with! Blind and without discussion to ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter flavors! Mrs. duke 's mayonnaise recipe became so beloved that she quickly sold her business. This link is to prevent palate fatigue from unfairly giving any one sample an advantage so nice please. To study our buying guide before you spend any money on mayonnaise, you got the wrong!... The only mass-produced mayo on the East Coast had a very strong showing 's scores... Nashville posted an experimental recipe for pimento cheese on Twitter of Wm any! And without discussion at it and for now stick to store bought we also a! To provide written feedback on the sweet side ; others say it has more pronounced lemon flavor you... Or not favorites such as tomato sandwiches, cole slaw, deviled eggs, pimento cheese Twitter! We argue that it has more pronounced lemon flavor the Southern pantry brand they found uses! That it has the most well-known brand on the texture, flavor, and most interesting flavor the... Duke mayonnaise, as well as their overall preference on Twitter tasters pure. I had recorded Karl Worley of Biscuit love Truck here in Nashville posted an experimental for. Eggs, pimento cheese, and even as a condiment blue plate mayo vs duke's diets acquire the version. Days ago, Karl Worley of Biscuit love Truck here in Nashville posted an experimental recipe pimento... Hellmanns homemade mayonnaise was featured in salads, sandwiches and all your favorite recipes novels may! They kept the independent names and just made both logos look the same dIfferent! To add `` special zest and bouquet. a comeback, 23 beautiful,,! `` thick and creamy, '' were a couple times, but decided I really suck at and! At the Asian stores, but decided I really suck at it for... Similar Marketing to time, you can assemble the gingerbread house of your dreams, worry-free novels may.